The Lunge

2 replies [Last post]
Laid back European . . . it has been said . .
Alan's picture
Offline
Joined: 2007-11-15
Points: 0
The Lunge

This exercise has been performed for several decades now, but has enjoyed increased popularity in the last few years. Rarely, do you enter a gym and not see someone performing the lunge in one form or other. I find this annoying . . . . . I have never liked the movement, have been injured doing them and  . . .  to cap it all, am no damn good at them! I have always avoided them like the plague.

I have been pretty much alone in my thoughts on this exercise, but I was delighted to read recently in an interview with weightlifting coach, John Broz, the following comments . . . . " I consider the lunge the worst exercise ever invented " . . . " it's not a natural movement. You never see a child lunge to pick something up - they squat ". . . . . .  " what happens with this movement is that you end up using a weight that is too heavy and end up twisting your knee " and lastly " you can get the same or better benefits from doing a squat, and it is much, much safer ".

When my wife and I lived in Australia for a while, she had a personal trainer who gave her bucket loads of these things to do and yes, guess what, she injured herself and has never done them since. I rest my case . . . . .  any comments ?

CSCS and WNBF PRO
Cytrainer913's picture
Offline
Joined: 2006-11-26
Points: 0

I really feel that it comes down to how this exercise is taught because you can do so many things wrong with it, but is used regularly by many physical therapists, and this to me is a good sign for the exercise.

Personally I love the exercise and have done it for year and have used up to 185 for 8 reps a side for walking lunges and the motion does mimic many movements just in a broken up fashion or in segments of the running motion. 

The stride for these should be elongated, so that when your upper body drops vertically down to the ground the front knee stays in line with the or just behind the toe. The weight and work should be done by the front leg as the back leg is just there to balance yourself. and the back foot should be up on the toe if all of these things are  met along with the last thing that many people do wring as well as you ascend back from the bottom of the lunge the weight and pressure of the move should primarily fall on the heel of the front leg, as is the case with any kind of leg press, squats, always push through the HEEL! Because essentially the lunge is a one legged SQUAT. The PT's also use this motion to where the patient will pulse in the lunge position to strengthen the muscles around the knee. 

 

So I am gonna have to disagree with you on the lunge and that they are a very good exercise. Must have been something being taught wrong.

Ran a 5k (www.cjsbus.org) with Cameron and Lynnea dominated the kids' dash - good way to start a Saturday!
Dr. Joe's picture
Offline
Joined: 2006-10-14
Points: 0

Doing walking lunges can be very hard on knees if someone already has knee problems or they start with too much weight or volume.  I've always preferred alternating reverse lunges - far better on your knees - but still rarely used them. My thoughts were much like yours, Alan.  But, I've found I have suffered some injuries due to not doing enough unilateral work that really hits your glutes.  Now that I do some weighted split squats and use lunges a little more often (not a lot), I find that I'm correcting some imbalances and I'm better off for it.  They won't build muscle on your quads at all, but they're a great secondary movement and great for glutes and functional strengthening.