Simple versus Complex Carbs

15 replies [Last post]
Ran a 5k (www.cjsbus.org) with Cameron and Lynnea dominated the kids' dash - good way to start a Saturday!
Dr. Joe's picture
Offline
Joined: 2006-10-14
Points: 0
Simple versus Complex Carbs

Question from a client today:

 

Are all carbs created equal?  In a precontest diet is it better to stick with "healthy" carb sources like veggies or is it okay to incorporate carbs like rice cakes, bread, wraps and etc...throughout the day?  For that matter, are protein sources like cottage cheese (fat free) and greek yogurt just as good as chicken, fish and the like?  I am trying to get some variety in my life but I want to eat the best things for maintaining muscle and losing fat at the same time. 

 

My reply:

When you look at carbs and qualify them by quality...things like Glycemic Index value, complexity (fiber, starch, sugar), etc, it's easy to conclude that complex, low-Glycemic is better....healthier, right?  You certainly need enough fiber to keep your GI system happy and moving and you don't want so much simple carb as to create really unstable blood sugar levels and insulin dumps, but you do need a good amount of starch and some sugar as an athlete.  It would be very inefficient to use just fibrous carb or stored fat as energy when you need it most - during training.  So, even prior to a good cardio session, I recommend a small simple carb, certainly before training even more quantity, and post-workout is a place you want some carbs to replenish enough glycogen to stop catabolism and increase recovery/anabolism.  So, get enough fiber, use enough starch to keep energy levels as high as possible, and use a little simple carb here and there for performance and recovery.

Back to the grind :(
zooxmusic's picture
Offline
Joined: 2010-02-01
Points: 3

NICE! Snickers after training

Dedicated to be the best I can be
castin's picture
Offline
Joined: 2009-12-24
Points: 0

I like to use a 20oz orange Gatorade with 1 1/2 scoop of vanilla protein in it after training. 35/35/1. Taste like those orange push pops you ate a kid. :bigsmile:

does not have a status.
admin's picture
Offline
Joined: 2010-04-22
Points: 1

Damn, that does sound good, I'm gonna stock up

@Ben Yea it should be a good one I guess there alot of guys doing it should be really competitive.
zack dery's picture
Offline
Joined: 2009-06-26
Points: 0

 or how about lo calorie vitamin water orangef lavor with orange flavor bcaa while you train ;) 

Dedicated to be the best I can be
castin's picture
Offline
Joined: 2009-12-24
Points: 0

Yeah that too :bigsmile:

Already excited for Fantasy Camp in January!
Sean's picture
Offline
Joined: 2009-02-02
Points: 0

Another great call by Dery....love vitamin water while training. I don't mix BCAA with it, but I have mixed vanilla whey with it PWO and I love that from time to time.

does not have a status.
James A's picture
Offline
Joined: 2010-07-16
Points: 0

Or in my case just a lot of sourdough bread...;)

@Ben Yea it should be a good one I guess there alot of guys doing it should be really competitive.
zack dery's picture
Offline
Joined: 2009-06-26
Points: 0

vanilla whey sounds good. 

staying positive and working hard
Annette's picture
Offline
Joined: 2008-07-24
Points: 0

hhmm, I usually take unflavored (so they say) BCAA powder with plain water and it is freakin' nasty.  I will have to try mixing it into that zero water by vitamin water.  That is a great idea.

@Ben Yea it should be a good one I guess there alot of guys doing it should be really competitive.
zack dery's picture
Offline
Joined: 2009-06-26
Points: 0

 or powerade zero to get some extra electrolytes ;)

Already excited for Fantasy Camp in January!
Sean's picture
Offline
Joined: 2009-02-02
Points: 0

My favorite is the full-sugar version of the yellow Vitamin water. Tropical Citrus I think? But that with a scoop and half of our whey is freaking awesome PWO.

Dedicated to be the best I can be
castin's picture
Offline
Joined: 2009-12-24
Points: 0

Anyone leave in the simple sugars during contest prep after training? I tried it this last time I think with good success

@Ben Yea it should be a good one I guess there alot of guys doing it should be really competitive.
zack dery's picture
Offline
Joined: 2009-06-26
Points: 0

 Yea Ive been using them in my pwo shake and on my high days and if my weight is ahead of schedule Ill put a lil honey or molasses pre workout on my oats.  Gives you a great pump!

Getting ready for OCB Florida State classic Sep 3rd.
LetsRageFitness's picture
Offline
Joined: 2011-03-27
Points: 0

I like doing 2Tbsp honey, 1 banana and 1/4 cup of raisins for carbs after my lifts with 50g of whey. keeping it to whole foods seems to work best for me.

Ran a 5k (www.cjsbus.org) with Cameron and Lynnea dominated the kids' dash - good way to start a Saturday!
Dr. Joe's picture
Offline
Joined: 2006-10-14
Points: 0

I saw some research a while back that showed whole food was just as appropriate.  Many got in the habit of wanting the massive insulin spike from a big, simple carb load, but they fail to realize that you still get a substantial insulin dump from just the size of a meal, not just the simplicity of the carb structure.  Even protein alone in a large enough amount will trigger a solid amount of insulin.  I do both, really just dependent upon how I feel post-workout or what time of the day it is.....if it's lunch time, I eat whole food.  If it's mid-afternoon, I'll likely do a scoop of superior, can't-be-duplicated, highly-anabolic, delicious-tasting Diet Doc Vanilla Bean Precision Protein Blend : )  and Vitamin Water.  It's the timing - getting food in as soon as you leave the gym floor that is most important.  Amount and structure are secondary to timing.